Monday, May 23, 2011

You're too skinny, you anorexic!

I've never been accused of being anorexic or been called skinny so I can't really relate but I can't help but feel the offense people bring to those who are very tiny and receive these comments. Not everyone achieves a tiny frame/waist through an eating disorder and some people are naturally born with a tiny frame or a fast metabolism.

Why is it that people immediately jump to the conclusion that someone is unhealthy when they're small or have lost a lot of weight? (Especially when they've either stated that's their family body build or that they ate healthy and exercised for their body? Did that completely go over your head?) People just like to look at what they see and judge it on the outside and the numbers, rather than the actual story.

You can look at a chart that you found online all you want at what a healthy weight is for a person, but you can be at any weight and still be unhealthy on the inside. Sometimes it doesn't matter how healthy or unhealthy a person could look on the outside. It depends on what they put in it. Someone who looks really fit could be on drugs. Someone who is chubby, could actually be eating healthy but have a slow metabolism.

There are a lot of people who are at an unhealthy weight, and everyone should go to their doctor and get a check up to know what you should be doing for your body, but just because someone looks too skinny doesn't mean they're unhealthy. Some girls really can't help it. How do you think they feel being picked on for something they can't change? They want to feel beautiful and accept too. Or how about someone who has been suffering an ED or has been overweight all their life and they can finally eat healthily and lost weight healthily but you're still telling them they're not good enough by telling them they're unhealthy/too skinny. Seriously?

This battle is never going to die down between skinny and fat because everyone has their own idea of what is right and what isn't. And when I say fat, I don't even mean obese. I mean fat percentage, fat placement, healthy fat. Fat isn't a bad word! There is such thing as GOOD FAT. People make it a bad word. Skinny too. The word skinny is so linked to the words diet, beauty, tiny, feminine, desirable, eating disorder. It's awful only because it's not just describing one thing, it describes a social mentality.

I'm completely guilty of wanting to be skinny but I'm doing it for health purposes both physically and mentally because I did suffer an ED once upon a time and I was unhappy with the way I was treating my body. So, I did something about it. It was my choice. But you know what? There are people who love their body even if they're consciously eating unhealthily. Let them because it's their choice. They don't need to be bullied into losing weight or eating healthy because that will make them think they're not good enough. They need to realize on their own to eat healthy FOR THEMSELVES. You don't need to leave them alone about it (unless they ask or you can visibly see it's making them feel bad), but be careful of your words and actions and how you go about doing it.

Same with smokers/drinkers, people who tan in the sun, and text while driving. Smokers, they know what bad things happen to their body but you can't force someone to stop. It's their decision. People who tan out in the sun a lot, too much sun exposure can cause bad things to your skin but they do it knowing the causes. Texting while driving, you know you shouldn't do it and even if you're "skilled" enough to. That doesn't mean someone else isn't going to hit you or you'll miss that one split second that could keep things from getting bad. People do things all the time that aren't always the best for them but that's not an excuse to place judgement on that person. To call them stupid, too this or too that. We all have our faults and problems that sometimes we could care less to fix or wait to fix even if we should. That's the way a lot of us are.

Have any of you been accused for being "too skinny" or brought down because you lost "too much weight"? Or just been told you need to do this or that because it's better for you? And how did you feel about it?

7 comments:

  1. i`m exactly this case kind of person, i`ve been skinny all my life, and by skinny a mean too skinny, i`m also very short, until i was in high school people never called me anorexic, but they used to tell me "you are a stick, eat more" that didn`t affect me back then, but when i was in college people started calling me anorexic and i was really affected, i had to reply back saying i just can`t gain weight, i even went to the doctor looking for a diet that makes me gain weight but it didn`t work, till now people still call me anorexic it doesn`t bother me anymore, there`s nothing i can do about it, but what really really really makes me mad is when a fat person (yes a real fat one) tells me "oh you are so skinny, poor you" i get too mad i often reply "at least i`m not a pig" i know is bad but they have not right to say that to me in the first place and with a pity tone. Till today i still try to gain weight but nothing works, good thing is that i can eat cake everyday XD

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh my gosh, I can't stand that when people talk down on you Dx
    That reminds me of something my friend told me when she was at the mall. How this much bigger girl that was passing by her blatantly said out loud to her own friend that my friend had a bad dye job. My friend had a big urge to say, "At least I can fix my hair tonight, but you'll still be fat." She's not the type to pick fights either or to make fun of people, but when someone offends you, first reactions tend to be retaliation xD
    Some things people say are so unnecessary x ___x

    ReplyDelete
  3. I lost about 40 pounds in two months just because I started exercising and eating right (which I NEVER did before)...people accused me of doing drugs in order to loose the weight :(
    PS: My sister's boyfriend and his sister have insanely high metabolisms and have to deal with people calling them anorexic. They have to eat twice as much as a normal person just to stay "normal" skinny!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Aw, honey. <33 People are bloddy ridiculous out there. :[ I've known 2 girls with EDs and I know what the running commentary can do to a gal.... I really hope folks wise up, find some tact (or compassion, or intelligence), and stop throwing around these words.
    * * *

    When I was little I was a stick, too. Like, no matter how much I ate (and I ate TWICE as much as most kids my age), I'd still be underweight. (It probably didn't help that my bro and I were SUPER active/on sports teams.) My pediatrician actually prescribed me Pediasure for about a year to supplement my diet. Haha.

    And then I got older and my metabolism evened out. I even gained a bit of 'chub' in middle school, when I hit puberty. I was average weight in HS, though.

    And then... I lost 15 pounds via a diet in my Freshman year of college, last year. And my. Family. Went. Nuts. Asked if I was eating, etc. So did other girls I knew from HS.

    Like, really? Ugh. So no, I'm not skinny, really. Or at least, I don't look it, I think, but I've had some weird accusations thrown my way. :/

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Noxin
    Foreal. I just don't understand why people do it. What's the point? I mean, no one wants to be spoken that way or treated that way.

    And then there's that x ___x' Just cause someone loses weight doesn't mean they've been starving themselves. That's one of the reasons why I eat a lot when I'm in public. I don't want people to think that I don't and if they think I eat too much at least they can see I'm enjoying it D<

    ReplyDelete
  6. Interesting blog read. I've been ED forums where its SKINNY vs FAT and it's just insanely ignorant on both sides to even judge someone based on their OWN body.

    From my personal opinion, I think people generally say things like "YOU GOT WAYY TOO SKINNY" or make it sound like you're anorexic when you're not because they probably are envious that you are/have lost so much weight. I'm guilty of calling my extremely skinny friends "TOO SKINNY" but for the most part, I really mean is at a friendly joke. But then I realize, what if they say I'm "TOO FAT"? I guess they wouldnt because that would be mean.

    But see, the problem is that society thinks being called "TOO SKINNY" is not even a bad thing. Let's face it, most people would rather be called TOO SKINNY or anorexic than TOO FAT or FATASS, obese, lard, etc. And that's because being overweight is attributed to over eating most of the time whereas most underweight people do it for something like vanity or have body dismorphia or whatever it's called. But nobody really accounts-for fat people who are fat because of genetics or skinny people who are skinny because of genetics.

    The fat vs skinny war will never end. It's one of those topics that can only be vented about with no true solution. Which is sad but it's the way that people judge one another in this society.

    If you're fat, you have curves. If you're skinny you are model thin. Every body type will start defending themselves as the better body type but like Art, our bodies have no definite "BETTER" or "WORSE", there is only HEALTHY and NOT HEALTHY, which is the real concern of any body type.Which is pretty much what you said but I just wanted to reiterate :P

    I deal with this particular situation pretty often but to be honest, it never really phases me because I realize I cannot change how people want to view me. My body fluctuates ALOT and the moment I lose a lot of weight, everyone around me wants to say I'm "TOO SKINNY' or "look unhealthy" and then at other times I'm "GETTING FAT", "TURNING INTO A FATBALL" etc. It's like, really, I can never win. I can never be "JUST RIGHT" and I think in reality, everyone wants to be "JUST RIGHT" when there is no true definition of such a thing. The closest to a real solution I think, is to just not give a shit what people have to say. If you are happy with your body, then you are happy with your body. If you aren't, you try to build muscle, gain weight, lose weight, or get ripped. If you don't succeed, then you just have to be satisfied with the way you were made. I think that's what keeps me from shooting myself every time I get some mean comment about my weight. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow I recently stumbled onto your blog and I just need express my love for this post, I have always been naturally skinny, too, and in my pre teens I started have troubles with my health which meant i had to take medication that made my appetite not very good, I have heard so many girls say "eew your so nasty and skinny" or "you have the body of a 12 year old boy" etc and people think it's ok to say that because skinny=happy but it's not true, it hurts a lot especially when there is nothing you can do about it. Anyway I'm really happy to see someone else understands and sees that people don't always choose to be very skinny. Thank you <3

    ReplyDelete